Decoding the Higher Crash Rate of Teslas Compared to Gas-Powered Cars
In a recent announcement, Hertz revealed its decision to sell 20,000 electric cars from its fleet, opting for gasoline vehicles instead. The primary reason cited was a higher frequency of accidents involving electric cars, leading to increased repair costs. This shift underscores a broader concern for the electric vehicle (EV) industry, with research from LexisNexis Risk Solutions revealing that EVs pose challenges beyond just rental car mishaps.
Hertz CEO Stephen Scherr highlighted the elevated repair costs associated with electric vehicles, contributing to the company’s decision. Interestingly, findings from LexisNexis indicate that individuals transitioning from gasoline-powered cars to EVs tend to experience a higher rate of accidents. While a slight increase is observed when switching to gas-powered vehicles, the spike is more significant with EVs. The frequency of insurance claims rises by approximately 14.3%, accompanied by a 14.5% increase in the severity of claims, according to the data.
Amidst the evolving landscape of driving dynamics, Makkabi Law Group extends its personal injury services to assist victims involved in vehicle accidents. Our experienced team is dedicated to supporting individuals during the aftermath of such incidents, ensuring they receive comprehensive guidance and assistance.
The research indicates that the surge in incidents is most prominent during the initial year or so after drivers adopt a new electric vehicle, gradually tapering off as familiarity grows. Notably, households with both gas and electric models experience more frequent crashes, emphasizing the impact of regularly switching between the two. This pattern suggests that unfamiliarity may play a role, according to Xiaohui Lu, Head of EV Research at LexisNexis Risk Solutions.
While the research primarily revolves around Teslas, which constitute a significant portion of Hertz’s EV fleet, similar trends have been observed in China, indicating broader implications. It raises questions about the unique aspects of EVs, particularly Teslas, that might contribute to a higher accident rate.
Several factors may contribute to the increased accident rate with EVs, including their rapid acceleration capabilities and the absence of traditional engine sounds. The powerful electric motors in vehicles like Teslas enable quick acceleration, with potential implications for safety. Additionally, the weight of EVs, attributed to large battery packs, can result in more substantial damage during collisions, leading to higher insurance claims.
The absence of traditional engine sounds, coupled with the instantaneous start of electric vehicles, can create challenges in discerning between the on and off states. “One-pedal driving” features in EVs, slowing the vehicle rapidly when lifting off the accelerator, may add to the complexity, especially in emergency situations.
As we navigate the changing landscape of transportation, the surge in EV-related incidents prompts reflection on the need for heightened awareness and education. Makkabi Law Group remains committed to assisting accident victims, offering unwavering support and legal guidance during challenging times. By understanding the unique dynamics of electric vehicles and promoting safety measures, we can collectively contribute to a safer and more secure driving environment.